31 Comments
User's avatar
Justin Lind's avatar

Jeff this is incredible. The structure of a letter to a past self was perfect. "Serving is not the same as indulging" hit me so powerfully. This applies to so many things outside of politics. I think so many people have been through a similarly dynamic political ride the last 8 years. Even if their details are different, even opposite of yours, I think you touched a piece of everyone here. I was riding along the whole time. Super emotional ending too. Thank you for this!

Expand full comment
Jeff Giesea's avatar

Thanks, Justin, for the acknowledgement. Appreciate your reading this!

Expand full comment
Helen House's avatar

Jeff Jeff Jefff… oh my heart! This is the man I know and love and who is so powerfully loving the world back into a place we might all feel at home in again one day. Thank you for writing this… to yourself… To us… to America… to Spencer… and your beautiful son.

Expand full comment
Jeff Giesea's avatar

Thanks Helen, appreciate your support <3

Expand full comment
Wild Pacific's avatar

Very beautiful and raw.

We need more of these. ❤️

Recently there have been quite a few mea culpas, from Hanania-adjacent ex-rightish thinkers. Which is very good. But also feeds my constant doubt:

Maybe for all this intelligentsia over invested in their own main weapon. 🧠

If middling IQ journalist could see orange scam for what it was, while supposedly Elite Human Capital were so engrossed in writing about writing, hanging out and podcasting with other high brow gay-or-straight bar-going, Twitter-storming, oh-so-smart crème ala crème that they could not. 🤓

Maybe all these pundits are worth much less that they claim, and what their book sale numbers and follower counts were supposed to indicate. 🏆

Maybe big heart and more basic principles is all we really need in political scene. 🌼

Maybe people voted 🍊 because the thinkers used long words and called them Low Human Capital few times too many. 🪙

Jeff shows a lot of reflection. He knows very well how much pain can transform a healthy mind, and how much of a puppet educated mind is to the quiet driver in our heart that is always holding the wheel. 🌟

Expand full comment
Jeff Giesea's avatar

All true

Expand full comment
The Ivy Exile's avatar

Sorry for your loss.

Expand full comment
Jeff Giesea's avatar

Thank you

Expand full comment
Alissa Mears's avatar

There were so many sentences I needed to read again for all they articulated: "It feels brotherly, but this is grief-stricken logic." And "You honor him by embracing your privilege and using it to serve, not by stewing in grievances like a sullen child. Serving is different from indulging." And especially that final sentence, just stunning. Thank you for this beautiful essay; thank you for being a good man.

Expand full comment
Jeff Giesea's avatar

Thanks Alissa!

Expand full comment
Steve Tulowitzki's avatar

Wonderfully raw, Jeff. Thanks for explaining to yourself and those who admire and respect you (that certainly includes me) this path you’ve traversed. I’m intrigued to see what’s next.

Expand full comment
Jeff Giesea's avatar

Thanks for your kind comments Steve.

Expand full comment
Stan's avatar

Wow Jeff. Thanks for sharing this. So much of what you’ve shared sounds like where in was in 2015 and where I am today. My youngest son is named Spencer. He turns 28 in December and has become a great man. You have so much to look forward to as you raise your son. He will emulate your actions and words. He’s lucky to have a father committed to growth and change. Keep up the good works. Cheers.

Expand full comment
Jeff Giesea's avatar

Thanks so much Stan

Expand full comment
Libby Fosters's avatar

"Earnestness, talent, and a chip on the shoulder is a dangerous combination. Ground yourself in your moral compass and learn to say no to certain people and situations." Great post, Jeff.

Expand full comment
Jeff Giesea's avatar

Thank you Libby

Expand full comment
John Fariello's avatar

Dear Jeff: this was such a profound introspective piece. I marvel at the causal relationship you draw between the loss of your brother and your involvement with Trump and his seizure of the Republican party. Trump's message was so seductive and struck the right chords with so many Americans they were (are) willing to overlook his complete unsuitability for office. His term as the emperor with new (no) clothes started with his claim that he had the largest crowds at his inauguration.

When I was 18, I lost my brother in a senseless car accident. He was 2 years younger and his death was not as affecting to me because he was 2 years younger. However, he was the "normal" one and would have had a large family and all that that implies. I miss him more than I usually admit. Religion was no consolation and I've rooted out the Catholic dogma that was so effectively planted. I'm also a lapsed Libertarian and I'm eager to follow your progress and see where it takes you. Warmest regards.

Expand full comment
Jeff Giesea's avatar

Thank you for the kind words John, and sorry for the loss of your brother. It is profound how long the thread of grief persists.

Expand full comment
Tommy Dixon's avatar

This was such a powerful essay Jeff. One I will continue to return to and reflect on.

Thank you for sharing. Big accomplishment to hit publish.

Expand full comment
Jeff Giesea's avatar

Thanks Tommy

Expand full comment
Emma Dorge's avatar

My initial response was “Holy Shit!” This was super powerful, Jeff. i echo Tommy’s comments. Congrats on your courage to write this.

Expand full comment
Randy Sifers's avatar

Thanks for sharing, Jeff. Very affecting.

Expand full comment
Jeff Giesea's avatar

Thanks Randy

Expand full comment
Richard Hanania's avatar

Thank you for sharing, quite touching.

Expand full comment
Jeff Giesea's avatar

I didn't realize you have emotions, Richard. But seriously, thanks for your support and friendship.

Expand full comment
kora 🌊's avatar

Jeff, this was so beautifully written. Thank you for sharing.

Expand full comment
Jeff Giesea's avatar

thank you!

Expand full comment
Latham Turner's avatar

This is beautiful and moving Jeff. Thanks for opening up so vulnerably.

Expand full comment
Jeff Giesea's avatar

thanks Latham!

Expand full comment
Sandra Yvonne's avatar

Wow, Jeff. This is both really insightful and moving. Thank you for sharing your story.

Expand full comment
Jeff Giesea's avatar

Thanks Sandra!

Expand full comment